Can you imagine the terror that gripped the small coal mining town of Logan, Ohio when young lovers Todd Schillitz and Annette Cooper mysteriously disappeared? In the first part of our chilling episode, we walk you through the couple's enchanting love story, the ominous rumors involving Annette's stepfather, Dale Johnson, and the unsettling discovery of their remains in a shallow grave. Together, we'll make sense of the disturbing twists and turns of the murder investigation, Dale's trial, and the shocking new evidence that surfaced years later.

Fasten your seatbelts as we plunge into the second half of our journey, unraveling a narrative that is as haunting as it is intriguing. We spotlight an unexpected confession from Chester McKnight and introduce you to the shadowy figure of Kenny Lynn Scott. Get ready to meet Judy, whose vivid memories of the fateful day Todd and Annette vanished, lead to an astonishing revelation. Despite Chester's life sentence and Kenny's release, the mystery surrounding Todd and Annette's murder persists. As we pay tribute to their unfulfilled dreams, we invite you to join us in exploring a tale of love, loss, and a murder mystery that still haunts a town.

Support the Show.